Valuation Caps and Discounts on SAFEs and Notes
Valuation caps and discounts determine how SAFEs and convertible notes turn into shares. Here is how each works, how they interact, and what founders should consider when setting them.
Key points
- Caps set a maximum conversion valuation; discounts reduce the conversion price.
- Investors convert at whichever gives the better price.
- Multiple SAFEs can stack up and create significant dilution.
- Set caps based on market evidence and model all conversions.
SAFEs and convertible notes let founders raise money without setting a valuation upfront. But they are not valuation-free. Valuation caps and discounts determine how many shares early investors receive when the instruments convert. Understanding them is essential for managing dilution and setting fair terms.
Valuation caps
A valuation cap sets the maximum valuation at which a SAFE or note converts into equity.
Example: an investor invests $250,000 on a SAFE with a $5 million cap. The company later raises a priced round at a $10 million pre-money valuation. The SAFE converts as if the valuation were $5 million, so the investor receives roughly twice as many shares per dollar as new investors.
Caps reward early investors for taking risk before the company has proven itself.
Discounts
A discount gives investors a reduced price compared with new investors in the priced round. Common discounts range from about 10 to 25 per cent.
Example: with a 20 per cent discount, if new investors pay $1.00 per share, the SAFE holder converts at $0.80 per share.
How caps and discounts interact
Many instruments include both a cap and a discount. The investor converts at whichever gives the lower price, and therefore more shares.
Example: a SAFE has a $6 million cap and a 20 per cent discount. The priced round is at an $8 million pre-money valuation.
- Cap price: based on $6 million.
- Discount price: 80 per cent of $8 million, equivalent to $6.4 million.
- The cap gives the better price, so the investor converts at the cap.
If the priced round were at $7 million, the discount would equate to $5.6 million, which is lower than the cap, so the discount would apply.
Uncapped instruments
Some instruments have no cap, only a discount, or a “most favoured nation” clause. Uncapped instruments are founder-friendly but less attractive to investors, because they do not protect against very high future valuations.
Setting caps and discounts
Founders should consider:
- Market norms: recent caps for similar companies.
- Expected next-round valuation: caps set too high may deter investors, while caps set too low can cause heavy dilution.
- Stacking: multiple SAFEs at different caps can create significant cumulative dilution.
- Investor relationships: fair terms build goodwill.
The stacking problem
Founders who issue many SAFEs over time often underestimate dilution. Each SAFE converts in the next priced round, and their combined effect can be substantial. Modelling all SAFEs on a pro forma cap table before issuing more is essential.
Common mistakes founders make
- Setting caps based on hopes rather than market evidence.
- Issuing multiple SAFEs without modelling cumulative dilution.
- Assuming caps represent agreed valuations for tax or other purposes.
- Using inconsistent terms across investors.
Regional considerations
Australia. SAFEs and convertible notes are both common, with caps and discounts used in similar ways to the US. Founders should consider ESIC implications, since tax incentives generally apply to newly issued shares.
United States. Post-money SAFEs with caps are standard, and discounts are common in convertible notes.
Europe. Convertible loans with caps and discounts are common in many countries. In the UK, SEIS and EIS investors typically use advance subscription agreements, which include discounts and sometimes caps, to remain eligible for tax relief.
Asia. Caps and discounts are common in SAFE-style instruments in Singapore and in J-KISS in Japan.
A practical example
A hypothetical founder issued three SAFEs over 18 months: $200,000 at a $3 million cap, $300,000 at a $5 million cap and $500,000 at an $8 million cap. When the company raised a seed round at a $10 million pre-money valuation, all three converted at their caps. As post-money SAFEs, together they converted into nearly 19 per cent of the company. The founder had assumed the SAFEs would be closer to 10 per cent, because she had considered each one in isolation.
Negotiating caps and discounts
Founders and investors often negotiate caps and discounts together. A higher cap may be balanced with a larger discount, or a lower cap may be offered to an investor who brings particular expertise or is first to commit. Some founders set a lower cap for a small first close to reward early conviction, then a higher cap for later investors. Whatever the approach, founders should keep a running pro forma model showing how all instruments will convert at different priced-round valuations.
A simple rule
Never issue a new convertible instrument without updating the pro forma cap table first.
Frequently asked questions
Is a valuation cap the same as a valuation?
No. A cap sets the maximum conversion valuation for the instrument. It is not an agreed valuation of the company.
What is a typical discount?
Discounts of 10 to 25 per cent are common, with 20 per cent frequently used.
Can I change the cap later?
Changing a cap requires agreement from the investor. It is better to set it carefully upfront.
What is a most favoured nation clause?
It allows an investor to adopt better terms granted to later investors in similar instruments.
Related reading
General information only. This article does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs, and it is not financial product, legal or tax advice or a recommendation. Figures are from the sources named and may change. Palo Alto Syndicate is a platform, not an adviser. It does not provide investment advice or recommendations. Every investment decision is yours. Early-stage investing is high risk. You could lose all the money you put in. See how the platform works and our terms of use.