palo alto
syndicate
Check eligibility
All articlesLaws and governance

Anti-Dilution Protection: Full Ratchet vs Weighted Average

Anti-dilution clauses protect investors if a startup later raises money at a lower price. Here is how full ratchet and weighted average protection work, why the difference matters, and what is standard by region.

Palo Alto Syndicate4 min read

Key points

  1. Anti-dilution protects investors in down rounds at the expense of other shareholders.
  2. Broad-based weighted average is the standard, founder-friendly approach.
  3. Full ratchet is aggressive and rare in healthy markets.
  4. Negotiate carve-outs and model the effect of potential down rounds.

Every investor hopes the companies they back will grow in value. But sometimes a startup has to raise money at a lower price than its previous round, known as a down round. Anti-dilution provisions protect investors in this situation by adjusting their conversion price so they receive more shares. For founders, the type of anti-dilution clause can make a significant difference to how much of the company they own after a difficult period.

Why anti-dilution exists

Investors who pay a high price per share face losses if the company later sells shares more cheaply. Anti-dilution clauses compensate them by adjusting the price at which their preferred shares convert into ordinary shares. The cost of that adjustment falls on other shareholders, usually founders and employees.

Full ratchet

Under full ratchet anti-dilution, the investor’s conversion price is reduced to the new, lower price, regardless of how many shares are issued in the down round.

Example: an investor paid $2.00 per share. The company later issues a small number of shares at $1.00. Under full ratchet, the investor’s conversion price drops to $1.00, effectively doubling the number of ordinary shares they would receive on conversion.

Full ratchet is very investor-friendly and can be extremely dilutive to founders. It is rare in healthy markets.

Weighted average

Weighted average anti-dilution adjusts the conversion price based on both the new price and the number of new shares issued. Small down rounds cause small adjustments; large down rounds cause larger ones.

There are two main variants:

  • Broad-based weighted average: includes all outstanding shares, options and convertible securities in the calculation. This results in smaller adjustments and is the most common and founder-friendly approach.
  • Narrow-based weighted average: includes only certain shares, resulting in larger adjustments for investors.

Comparing outcomes

Imagine an investor who paid $2.00 per share and a down round at $1.50 that issues a moderate number of shares relative to the company’s total. Under full ratchet, the investor’s conversion price falls to $1.50. Under broad-based weighted average, it might fall only to around $1.90, depending on the numbers. The difference in dilution to founders can be substantial.

Carve-outs

Anti-dilution clauses usually exclude certain share issues, such as:

  • Shares issued under employee option plans.
  • Shares issued on conversion of existing securities.
  • Shares issued in approved acquisitions or partnerships.

Founders should ensure carve-outs are broad enough to avoid unintended triggers.

Pay-to-play

Some deals include pay-to-play provisions, which require investors to participate in future rounds to keep their anti-dilution rights or preferred status. These encourage existing investors to support the company in difficult times.

Common mistakes founders make

  • Agreeing to full ratchet without understanding its effect.
  • Failing to negotiate adequate carve-outs.
  • Not modelling the impact of a potential down round.
  • Assuming a down round will never happen.

Regional norms

Australia. Broad-based weighted average anti-dilution is common in Australian venture deals, consistent with local template documents. Full ratchet is uncommon.

United States. Broad-based weighted average is the standard in NVCA documents. Full ratchet is rare outside distressed situations.

Europe. Broad-based weighted average is common, though terms vary by country. UK SEIS and EIS rules can affect the use of certain preferential rights.

Asia. Practice varies. Singapore’s VIMA templates use weighted average protection, while some investors in other markets have historically sought stronger terms.

A practical example

A hypothetical startup raised a Series A at $3.00 per share, then faced a difficult market and raised a Series B at $2.00 per share. Its Series A investors held broad-based weighted average protection, which adjusted their conversion price to about $2.70. The founders’ dilution from the adjustment was meaningful but manageable. A peer company with full ratchet protection in a similar situation saw its investors’ conversion price drop all the way to $2.00, leaving its founders with a much smaller share of the company and less motivation to continue.

Questions to ask before signing

Founders should ask their lawyers to show them the exact anti-dilution formula in the documents, which securities count in the broad-based calculation, and which share issues are carved out. They should also ask whether investors would be willing to waive anti-dilution rights in a future down round if they participate. Understanding these details before signing avoids unpleasant surprises in a difficult market.

The bigger lesson

The best protection against anti-dilution adjustments is avoiding down rounds altogether. Raising at realistic valuations, managing runway carefully and reaching milestones before raising all reduce the chance that anti-dilution clauses are ever triggered.

Frequently asked questions

What is a down round?

A down round is a funding round in which shares are sold at a lower price than in a previous round.

Does anti-dilution apply to ordinary shareholders?

No. Anti-dilution protection typically applies only to preferred shares held by investors.

Can anti-dilution rights be waived?

Yes. Investors sometimes waive anti-dilution rights in a down round to support the company, particularly if they are also investing.

Does anti-dilution matter if the company keeps growing?

Not directly, because it is only triggered by a down round. But founders should still negotiate it carefully, because markets can change unexpectedly.

General information only. This article does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs, and it is not financial product, legal or tax advice or a recommendation. Figures are from the sources named and may change. Palo Alto Syndicate is a platform, not an adviser. It does not provide investment advice or recommendations. Every investment decision is yours. Early-stage investing is high risk. You could lose all the money you put in. See how the platform works and our terms of use.

A new article every Monday.

Market news, investor education, founder guides, values investing and the rules, in plain English. Follow by RSS, or join the waitlist to hear when seats open.