409A, Fair Market Value and Tax Valuations for Startup Equity
Startups need formal valuations for tax and employee equity purposes, separate from funding round prices. Here is how 409A valuations, Australian ESS valuation methods and UK EMI valuations work.
Key points
- Tax valuations determine option strike prices and employee tax outcomes.
- Ordinary shares are usually worth less than preferred shares.
- The US uses 409A valuations; Australia allows ATO-approved safe harbour methods; the UK allows HMRC-agreed EMI valuations.
- Update valuations after funding rounds and material events.
When a startup grants options or shares to employees, tax authorities need to know what those shares are worth. That value is often different from the price investors paid in the last funding round. Formal tax valuations help companies set option strike prices correctly and help employees avoid unexpected tax costs.
Why tax valuations differ from funding round prices
Investors usually buy preferred shares with rights such as liquidation preferences. Employees typically receive options over ordinary shares, which lack those rights. As a result, the fair market value of ordinary shares is often lower than the preferred share price.
United States: 409A valuations
Section 409A of the US Internal Revenue Code governs deferred compensation, including stock options. To avoid penalties, options must be granted with a strike price at least equal to fair market value. Companies commonly obtain independent 409A valuations, which provide a “safe harbour” presumption of reasonableness if done properly.
409A valuations are typically updated at least annually and after material events such as funding rounds.
Australia: ESS valuation methods
Under Australia’s employee share scheme rules, the market value of shares in unlisted companies must be determined for tax purposes. The ATO has approved safe harbour valuation methods that eligible unlisted companies can use, such as methods based on net tangible assets, as an alternative to independent valuations. These methods can simplify valuation for early-stage companies.
Companies using the startup concession should ensure options are granted with an exercise price at least equal to market value to meet the concession’s conditions.
United Kingdom: EMI valuations
For EMI options, companies can agree the market value of shares with HMRC before granting options. This provides certainty that options granted at that value will qualify for favourable tax treatment. Agreed valuations are typically valid for a limited period.
Asia
- Singapore: valuations for employee equity follow general tax principles, with independent valuations often used.
- India: valuations for employee stock options are typically performed by registered valuers.
- Japan: tax-qualified stock options have specific valuation requirements.
When to update valuations
- After funding rounds.
- After significant business changes.
- Periodically, such as annually.
- Before large option grants.
Common mistakes founders make
- Granting options without a proper valuation.
- Using funding round prices for ordinary share valuations without adjustment.
- Failing to update valuations after funding rounds.
- Not documenting valuation methods.
A practical example
A hypothetical US startup raised a Series A at $2.00 per preferred share. Its 409A valuation, which considered the preferred shares’ rights and the lack of liquidity for ordinary shares, set the fair market value of ordinary shares at $0.60. The company granted options at $0.60, giving employees a meaningful potential gain. An Australian subsidiary used an ATO-approved safe harbour method to value shares for local employees, ensuring compliance with ESS rules.
Why timing matters for option grants
The timing of option grants relative to funding rounds can significantly affect employees. Options granted shortly before a funding round, using a valuation that predates the round, may have a lower strike price. However, valuations must reflect material information, and granting options at a stale valuation just before a major round can create tax risks. Founders should work with advisors to time grants appropriately and update valuations when required.
Communicating with employees about valuations
Employees often ask why their option strike price differs from the price investors paid. Founders should explain that ordinary shares and preferred shares have different rights, and that tax rules require a fair market value for ordinary shares. Clear communication helps employees understand the potential value of their equity and avoids confusion.
Record keeping
Companies should keep records of every valuation, including the method used, the date, the assumptions and any approvals. These records support the company’s position if tax authorities review option grants, and they are reviewed during due diligence for funding rounds and acquisitions.
Cross-border teams
Companies with employees in several countries may need valuations that satisfy multiple tax systems. A US parent company with an Australian subsidiary, for example, may need a 409A valuation for US employees and an ESS-compliant valuation for Australian employees. Advisors with cross-border experience can help design an approach that meets each country’s requirements efficiently.
Getting advice
Valuation rules are technical and vary between countries. Founders should work with accountants or valuation specialists familiar with employee equity in each jurisdiction where they grant options, and review their approach whenever the company raises capital or changes structure.
Frequently asked questions
Why is my 409A valuation lower than my funding round price?
Because ordinary shares lack the preferences and rights of preferred shares, and are less liquid.
How often should I update a 409A valuation?
At least annually and after material events such as funding rounds.
Do Australian startups need independent valuations?
Not always. Eligible unlisted companies can use ATO-approved safe harbour methods for ESS purposes.
What happens if options are granted below fair market value?
Employees may face adverse tax consequences, and companies may face penalties or loss of concessional treatment.
Related reading
General information only. This article does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs, and it is not financial product, legal or tax advice or a recommendation. Figures are from the sources named and may change. Palo Alto Syndicate is a platform, not an adviser. It does not provide investment advice or recommendations. Every investment decision is yours. Early-stage investing is high risk. You could lose all the money you put in. See how the platform works and our terms of use.