SAFEs, Convertible Notes and KISS: Choosing a Seed Instrument by Region
SAFEs, convertible notes and KISS instruments let founders raise early money without setting a valuation. Here is how each works, their pros and cons, and which instruments are standard in Australia, the USA, Europe and Asia.
Key points
- Convertible instruments defer valuation and speed up early rounds.
- SAFEs are simple but can stack up and dilute heavily.
- Convertible notes add interest and maturity dates, which can create pressure.
- Local norms and tax schemes should shape your choice of instrument.
At the earliest stages, agreeing on a valuation can be difficult. There is little data, and both founders and investors are guessing. Convertible instruments solve this by deferring the valuation until a later priced round. They are faster and cheaper than priced equity rounds, which is why they dominate early-stage fundraising in many markets.
How convertible instruments work
A convertible instrument is an investment that converts into equity at a future financing event, typically the next priced round. Investors receive a benefit for taking early risk, usually through:
- A valuation cap: the maximum valuation at which the investment converts.
- A discount: a percentage reduction on the price paid by new investors.
Investors typically convert at whichever gives them the better price.
SAFEs
The Simple Agreement for Future Equity was introduced by Y Combinator in 2013 and updated in 2018 to a post-money form. A SAFE is not debt. It has no interest rate and no maturity date. It simply converts into shares when the company raises a priced round.
Advantages:
- Simple, short and inexpensive.
- No interest or repayment obligation.
- Widely understood in the US and increasingly elsewhere.
Disadvantages:
- Multiple SAFEs can stack up and cause significant dilution.
- Investors have limited rights until conversion.
- There is no deadline forcing conversion if the company never raises a priced round.
Convertible notes
A convertible note is a loan that converts into equity. It carries an interest rate and a maturity date by which it must either convert or be repaid.
Advantages:
- Familiar to investors in many markets.
- Debt status can offer investors more protection.
- Interest increases the investor’s eventual equity.
Disadvantages:
- Maturity dates can create pressure if the company has not raised.
- Accrued interest increases dilution.
- Debt on the balance sheet can affect some company metrics.
KISS and other variants
The Keep It Simple Security was developed by 500 Startups as an alternative to the SAFE. It comes in debt and equity versions and includes some investor protections not found in the original SAFE, such as information rights and a maturity mechanism in the debt version.
Other markets have developed their own variants. Japan’s J-KISS, introduced by a local venture firm, is now widely used there.
Which instrument is standard where
Australia. Convertible notes have long been common, but SAFEs adapted for Australian law are now widely used. Local law firms and investors have published Australian versions of seed documents. Founders should check whether their instrument affects ESIC eligibility, because the tax incentives generally apply to newly issued shares rather than to convertible instruments until conversion.
United States. The post-money SAFE is the dominant early-stage instrument, particularly in Silicon Valley. Convertible notes are still used, especially outside major hubs.
Europe. Practice varies. In the UK, SAFEs are generally avoided for SEIS and EIS investments, because the schemes require investors to receive ordinary shares rather than convertible instruments. Advance subscription agreements are sometimes used instead. In continental Europe, convertible loans are common, with country-specific structures.
Asia. Singapore has adopted SAFE-style instruments widely. Japan uses J-KISS. In India and other markets, compulsorily convertible instruments are common, shaped by local foreign investment rules.
How to choose
Consider:
- Market norms: use what local investors expect.
- Tax incentives: make sure the instrument does not disqualify investors from schemes such as ESIC or SEIS.
- Cap table impact: model conversions carefully, especially if you plan to raise multiple times before a priced round.
- Speed and cost: standard documents keep legal costs down.
A practical example
A hypothetical startup raised $300,000 on a post-money SAFE with a $4 million cap, then a further $500,000 a year later on another post-money SAFE with a $6 million cap. When it raised a priced seed round at a $10 million pre-money valuation, both SAFEs converted at their caps, because the caps gave investors a better price than the round itself.
The first SAFE converted into 7.5 per cent of the post-money capitalisation implied by its cap, and the second into about 8.3 per cent. Together the two instruments took nearly 16 per cent of the company before the seed investors’ own stake was counted. The founders had assumed the SAFEs would cost them closer to 8 per cent, because they had looked at each one in isolation. Had they modelled both conversions on a single pro forma cap table before issuing the second SAFE, they might have negotiated a higher cap or raised a smaller amount.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a pre-money and post-money SAFE?
A pre-money SAFE calculates conversion before new SAFE money is included, so the dilution from multiple SAFEs is shared with existing holders less transparently. A post-money SAFE fixes the investor’s ownership percentage immediately, making dilution easier for founders to calculate.
Can a convertible note be repaid instead of converting?
Yes, in some cases. If a note reaches maturity without a qualifying financing, investors may have the right to request repayment, convert at a set valuation or extend the maturity. Most investors prefer conversion or extension rather than forcing repayment.
Do convertible instruments qualify for tax incentives?
Often not until they convert. Schemes such as ESIC in Australia and SEIS and EIS in the UK generally require newly issued shares. Check the rules carefully before structuring a round around tax incentives.
Related reading
General information only. This article does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs, and it is not financial product, legal or tax advice or a recommendation. Figures are from the sources named and may change. Palo Alto Syndicate is a platform, not an adviser. It does not provide investment advice or recommendations. Every investment decision is yours. Early-stage investing is high risk. You could lose all the money you put in. See how the platform works and our terms of use.