palo alto
syndicate
Check eligibility
All articlesMarket and funding

Earn-outs and Deal Structures in Startup Acquisitions

Earn-outs tie part of an acquisition price to the startup's future performance. Here is how earn-outs and other deal structures work, their benefits and risks, and how founders can negotiate them.

Palo Alto Syndicate4 min read

Key points

  1. Earn-outs link part of the acquisition price to future performance.
  2. They bridge valuation gaps but create risks for founders.
  3. Negotiate clear targets and operational protections.
  4. Consider escrow, share consideration and retention packages.

When buyers and sellers disagree on a startup’s value, earn-outs can bridge the gap. An earn-out makes part of the purchase price contingent on future performance. Earn-outs can unlock deals, but they also create risks and potential disputes.

How earn-outs work

  1. Upfront payment: the buyer pays part of the price at closing.
  2. Contingent payments: additional payments depend on achieving targets.
  3. Measurement period: targets are measured over a set period, often one to three years.

Targets may include revenue, earnings, customer milestones or product milestones.

Benefits

  • Bridging valuation gaps.
  • Aligning incentives between sellers and buyers.
  • Reducing buyer risk.

Risks for founders

  • Loss of control: the buyer controls the business after closing.
  • Integration changes that affect performance.
  • Disputes over calculations.
  • Uncertainty about final proceeds.

Negotiating earn-outs

  • Clear targets and calculation methods.
  • Operational protections, such as commitments on resources.
  • Acceleration on certain events.
  • Dispute resolution mechanisms.
  • Reasonable timeframes.

Other deal structures

  • Escrow and holdbacks: part of the price held to cover claims.
  • Share consideration: payment in buyer shares.
  • Deferred consideration: fixed payments over time.
  • Retention packages: incentives for employees.

Regional perspectives

Australia. Earn-outs are common in Australian acquisitions, particularly for founder-led businesses. Tax treatment of earn-outs should be considered.

United States. Earn-outs are common, with disputes sometimes litigated.

Europe. Earn-outs are common, with varying legal frameworks.

Asia. Earn-outs are used, with structures varying by market.

A practical example

A hypothetical Australian marketing technology startup was acquired for $20 million upfront and up to $10 million in earn-out payments based on revenue targets over two years. The founders negotiated commitments that the buyer would maintain sales resources and that the earn-out would accelerate if the business was sold. They achieved most of the targets and received $8 million of the earn-out.

Choosing earn-out metrics

The choice of metric is critical. Revenue-based targets are often simpler to measure and less affected by the buyer’s cost allocations than earnings-based targets. Earnings targets can be affected by integration costs, shared services and accounting decisions made by the buyer. Product or customer milestones can be useful where revenue is not yet meaningful. Founders should choose metrics they can influence and that are measured objectively.

Protecting the earn-out after closing

Because the buyer controls the business after closing, founders should negotiate protections, such as:

  • Commitments to operate the business consistently with past practice.
  • Agreed budgets and resources for sales, marketing and product.
  • Restrictions on changes that would undermine the earn-out, such as moving key customers to other business units.
  • Information rights to track progress.

Alternatives to earn-outs

Founders who prefer certainty may negotiate alternatives, such as a higher upfront payment with a smaller holdback, deferred fixed payments or a portion of consideration in buyer shares. Each alternative has different risks. Share consideration, for example, depends on the buyer’s share price.

Earn-outs and employees

Earn-outs often depend on key employees staying with the business. Retention packages for important team members can support earn-out targets and reduce the risk of departures after closing.

Resolving disputes

Earn-out disputes are common. Agreements should include clear calculation methods, examples and a process for resolving disagreements, such as independent expert determination. Clear drafting reduces the risk of costly litigation.

How buyers view earn-outs

Buyers see earn-outs as a way to share risk. If the business performs as the founders predict, the buyer pays the full price. If it does not, the buyer pays less. Buyers also use earn-outs to keep founders motivated during the transition, which can be critical when the business depends heavily on the founders’ relationships and expertise.

When earn-outs work well

Earn-outs tend to work best when:

  • The business will continue to operate largely independently after the acquisition.
  • Targets are realistic and based on clear, objective metrics.
  • The founders will remain in charge of the business during the earn-out period.
  • The buyer and sellers trust each other and share a vision for the business.

When to be cautious

Founders should be cautious when the buyer plans to integrate the business quickly, when targets depend on factors outside the founders’ control or when the earn-out represents a large share of the total price. In these cases, negotiating a larger upfront payment may be wiser.

Earn-outs for investors

Investors in the startup are also affected by earn-outs, because part of their return becomes contingent. Investors may prefer simpler structures with more upfront cash, and their preferences should be considered when negotiating the deal.

The bottom line

An earn-out is only as good as its drafting and the relationship behind it. Founders who negotiate clear metrics, realistic targets and operational protections give themselves the best chance of receiving the full price.

Frequently asked questions

Are earn-outs common?

Yes, particularly when buyers and sellers disagree on value.

Can earn-outs lead to disputes?

Yes, often over calculations and the buyer’s operation of the business.

How long do earn-outs last?

Often one to three years.

Are earn-outs taxed?

Tax treatment varies and should be considered with professional advice.

General information only. This article does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs, and it is not financial product, legal or tax advice or a recommendation. Figures are from the sources named and may change. Palo Alto Syndicate is a platform, not an adviser. It does not provide investment advice or recommendations. Every investment decision is yours. Early-stage investing is high risk. You could lose all the money you put in. See how the platform works and our terms of use.

A new article every Monday.

Market news, investor education, founder guides, values investing and the rules, in plain English. Follow by RSS, or join the waitlist to hear when seats open.